Benefits: As a Valued Agent Team Member you will enjoy…
Hourly Pay + Commission and Bonuses
Medical, Dental & Vision Benefits
Simple IRA Retirement Plan with Company Match
Term Life Insurance (if eligible)
Paid Time Off (10-15 days paid and 50 hours unpaid)
Licensing reimbursement up to $500 after 90 days - plus CE & renewal fees covered
Regular professional development - twice a month trainings + mentorship
Career incentives - opportunities to earn extra PTO, travel, swag and more
Personal touches - birthday gifts, anniversary "SF Bucks," and a team that sees and celebrates you
Comfortable office perks - free snacks, coffee and a personalized workspace
Purpose-driven work - help people understand and protect what matters most
What We’re Looking For: We’re looking for an energetic and customer-focused Customer Service Representative to be the face of our agency! This person plays a key role in shaping first impressions and delivering exceptional experiences to every customer who contacts us. The ideal candidate will be skilled at problem-solving, able to handle a high volume of daily interactions, and comfortable identifying opportunities to educate customers about our products and services.
A strong candidate will bring the following qualifications and traits:
Must be able to obtain or have an active Property & Casualty Insurance License (required prior to start)
Exceptional communication and problem-solving skills
Ability to manage 50+ customer interactions daily across phone, email, text, and walk-ins
High attention to detail and strong organizational habits
Ability to remain calm, empathetic, and professional in challenging customer situations
Self-motivated with a team-oriented, high-performance mindset
Key Responsibilities:
Own the front desk experience and serve as the first point of contact for customers via phone, email, text, and in-person visits
Quickly identify customer needs and proactively resolve questions, concerns, or problems
Handle upset or concerned customers with empathy and professionalism, clearly communicating the “why behind the what”
Manage and follow up on all underwriting memos to ensure timely policy processing
Maintain detailed and accurate customer records within agency systems
Proactively identify opportunities to educate customers on additional products (pivots/cross-sell opportunities)
Support customer retention and satisfaction efforts at every customer touchpoint
Maintain an organized, welcoming, and professional front office environment
Why Choose a Career with Allen State Farm Insurance? We believe hard work should be celebrated — when our team hits annual goals, everyone enjoys a fully paid week off during Christmas or New Year’s to relax and recharge with loved ones (in addition to regular time off!). Here's what else makes our agency stand out
No nights or weekends - and we keep it fun with Casual Fridays
Woman-owned & family-run - with a relationship-first culture
This isn't just a job -- it's a place where you can grow, make a difference, and be part of something meaningful.
Compensation Structure
Base Pay (without commission, no prior experience) = $36,400
Average Salary (with commission) = $54,600
Top Earners (with commission) = $76,000+
Numbers & Facts
Location
Bloomington, IN
Job Type
Full-time
Skills
Communication Skillsunmatched
Cross-Sellingunmatched
Customer Experienceunmatched
Customer Relationsunmatched
Customer Retention/Renewalunmatched
Customer Satisfactionunmatched
Customer Support/Serviceunmatched
Customer Trainingunmatched
Detail Orientedunmatched
Insuranceunmatched
Licensingunmatched
Mentoringunmatched
Needs Assessmentunmatched
Organizational Skillsunmatched
Problem Solving Skillsunmatched
Property and Casualty Insuranceunmatched
Reimbursementunmatched
Resolve Customer Issuesunmatched
Retirement Planunmatched
Team Playerunmatched
Time Managementunmatched
Underwritingunmatched
🎯
Be found by employers
5,500+ employers search our resume database daily. Add yours to get found by recruiters looking for candidates like you.
Level up your application
Professional resume templates
Browse dozens of recruiter approved resume templates, layouts and formats. Choose your favorite and make it your own in minutes.