First-Party Property Coverage Attorney

Pay: $120,000.00 - $170,000.00 per year

Why This Is a Great Opportunity

• Join an established first-party property coverage practice handling sophisticated commercial and residential insurance matters
• Work on complex property losses, policy interpretation, claim investigations, coverage analysis, and litigation
• Gain hands-on responsibility with examinations under oath, depositions, motions, mediations, and case strategy
• Enjoy a flexible hybrid schedule combining remote work with in-office collaboration
• Earn a competitive base salary plus discretionary bonus opportunities and robust benefits
• Benefit from mentorship, professional development, and a defined path toward partnership and potential equity ownership
• Work with experienced attorneys representing major insurers in significant first-party property disputes
• Join a supportive culture that values collaboration, professional growth, and work-life balance

Location:

Tampa, Florida. This is a flexible hybrid opportunity combining in-office collaboration with remote work.

Note:

Candidates must have an active Florida Bar license and 2+ years of directly relevant first-party property coverage experience.

About Us

Confidential Employer. We are an established civil litigation firm with a nationally recognized insurance coverage practice. For more than four decades, our attorneys have represented insurers, corporations, and insured clients in complex property coverage matters throughout the United States and internationally. We provide attorneys with sophisticated work, mentorship, professional development, and meaningful opportunities for long-term career advancement.

Job Description

• Analyze complex first-party property insurance policies and coverage issues
• Advise insurance clients throughout claim investigation and pre-suit coverage analysis
• Handle first-party property coverage disputes from initial investigation through litigation and resolution
• Conduct examinations under oath and participate in depositions
• Draft coverage opinions, pleadings, motions, briefs, discovery, and other substantive legal documents
• Work with experts and consultants regarding complex commercial and residential property losses
• Represent clients in mediations, hearings, negotiations, and other dispute-resolution proceedings
• Develop litigation and settlement strategies based on policy language, damages, and claim exposure
• Manage multiple active matters while meeting client reporting and litigation deadlines
• Collaborate with experienced coverage attorneys on complex and high-value insurance disputes

Qualifications

• 2+ years of first-party property coverage experience
• JD from an accredited law school
• Active Florida Bar license in good standing
• Experience analyzing property insurance policies and coverage issues
• Experience with EUOs, depositions, pleadings, motions, or mediations preferred
• Commercial or residential property coverage litigation experience preferred
• Strong legal research, analytical, writing, and oral advocacy skills
• Excellent client communication, organization, and time-management abilities
• Ability to manage multiple active matters and urgent deadlines
• Collaborative, detail-oriented, team-first approach

Why You Will Love Working Here

You will join a sophisticated insurance coverage practice where attorneys receive meaningful responsibility and exposure to complex property claims. Our team emphasizes mentorship, collaboration, work-life balance, and long-term professional growth. Attorneys interested in developing deep first-party property expertise will have opportunities to expand their practice, strengthen client relationships, and pursue advancement toward partnership.

JPC-2317

Benefits:

• Dental insurance
• Health insurance
• Life insurance
• Paid time off
• Retirement plan
• Vision insurance

Requirements:

• FL bar license. 2+ yrs first-party property coverage exp

• Required Years as Associate: 2+ years of first-party property coverage experience
• Salary Bands (Only if attorney role):

$120,000 to $135,000 for 2 to 3 years; 

$135,000 to $150,000 for 4 to 5 years; 

$150,000 to $170,000 for 6+ years. 

Client-provided salary range: $120,000 to $170,000.

Submission Email: Mac-

mrick@butler.legal

ajacobs@butler.legal

Quick Recruiter Reference

Tampa hybrid First-Party Property Coverage Attorney handling sophisticated insurer-side commercial and residential property coverage matters. Need active FL Bar license plus 2+ years of first-party property coverage experience. Target candidates with policy analysis, EUOs, coverage opinions, depositions, motions, mediations, and property insurance litigation experience.

Recruiters Submission: To submit, cancel - First-Party Property Coverage Attorney - Butler Weihmuller Katz Craig LLP - JPC- 2317 - source

New Job Order Alert

Client job title: First-Party Property Coverage Attorney

Location: Tampa, FL

On-site, hybrid, remote: Hybrid

Experience: 2

Good fit job titles/keywords for candidates: First-Party Property Coverage Attorney, Insurance Coverage Attorney, Property Coverage Attorney, Insurance Coverage Associate, Coverage Counsel, First-Party Property Attorney, Coverage Litigation Attorney, Property Insurance Attorney

of hires needed: 1