Insurance Customer Service Rep

The Dalton McCarthy Agency is a growing, high-performing insurance agency built on trust and a team-first culture. After managing the agency since 2017, Dalton purchased the business from his father and has continued building a productive, growth-oriented organization focused on long-term success. Our team is close-knit, supportive, and collaborative. We know that employees perform best when they enjoy their work environment and feel trusted to manage their responsibilities. That is why we promote a relaxed work environment that gives team members flexibility and freedom while still maintaining strong standards. Over the last year, our agency has become one of the more productive agencies in New York, and we are continuing to grow our team to support that momentum.

We're seeking a dependable Insurance Customer Service Representative to support our growing client base. This role is ideal for someone who enjoys helping people and creating positive customer experiences. You will assist customers with policy servicing, billing inquiries, account management, and retention-focused conversations.

• Base hourly pay of $20-$26 per hour, based on experience
• Bonus opportunities and performance incentives
• Monday-Friday schedule with evenings and weekends off
• Paid time off and paid holidays
• Retirement plan
• Opportunity to advance into an Office Manager role

If you are organized, compassionate, and enjoy building strong customer relationships, apply today!

Salary Range: $20 - $26 per hour

Hourly Base Salary + Commission + Bonus Opportunities

Paid Time Off (PTO)

Hands on Training

Mon-Fri Schedule

Career Growth Opportunities

Retirement Plan

Bonus Opportunities

Warm Leads Provided

Licensing Assistance

Work-Life Balance

Holidays Off

Paid Holidays

Advancement Opportunities

Performance Bonuses

Professional Work Environment

• Service customer accounts and insurance policies
• Assist clients with billing questions and account updates
• Manage customer relationships and provide exceptional support
• Initiate cross-sell conversations with existing customers
• Respond to client inquiries through phone, email, and text communication
• Help maximize customer satisfaction and retention

• Insurance license required
• Strong commitment to customer satisfaction
• Excellent phone and communication skills
• Patience, compassion, and professionalism with clients
• Ability to communicate effectively through phone, email, and text