Insurance Customer Service Rep

Fortner Insurance Services is an independent agency built around personalized service, knowledgeable guidance, and lasting client relationships. We believe that leadership means supporting our team, recognizing contributions, and creating opportunities for employees to learn and grow. Here, youll work with a close-knit team where your ideas are heard, and coworkers genuinely support one another. Your day will focus on managing client accounts, coordinating with carriers, handling service requests, and making sure clients receive thoughtful attention throughout the insurance process. Employees value the trust, appreciation, and opportunity to learn and take on greater responsibility.

As an Insurance Customer Service Rep in our Ministry Department, you'll serve as a trusted point of contact for ministry and church clients while managing their day-to-day insurance needs. Youll review accounts, process policy changes and renewals, communicate with carriers, and proactively follow up on outstanding items. This role offers hands-on training, professional development, and opportunities to expand your responsibilities within a personal, family-oriented workplace.

• Base pay is $19 to $22 per hour, based on experience
• Paid time off and paid holidays off
• Life and supplemental insurance
• Monday through Friday with evenings and weekends off

Bring your insurance knowledge and service mindset to a team where your work is valued and growth is encouraged, apply today!

Salary Range: $19 - $22 per hour

Hourly Base Salary + Bonus Opportunities

Paid Time Off (PTO)

Life Insurance

Hands on Training

Mon-Fri Schedule

Bonus Opportunities

Work-Life Balance

Holidays Off

Paid Holidays

Professional Development

Advancement Opportunities

Continuing Education Opportunities

Professional Work Environment

Team Building Activities

Equipment Provided

Office Snacks and Coffee

Supplemental Insurance

Personal Workspace

• Manage relationships with not-for-profit and church clients.
• Review accounts, policies, and coverage needs.
• Process changes, renewals, certificates, and endorsements.
• Communicate with carriers and underwriters.
• Follow up on renewals and outstanding items.
• Maintain accurate client records and documentation.

• Current P&C (property & casualty) MO license
• 2-3 years industry experience with working knowledge of AMS360 a bonus
• Highly organized and detail-oriented.
• Strong problem-solving mindset.
• Insurance knowledge and desire to learn.
• Proactive, dependable, and accountable.
• Compassionate and service-oriented approach.