Store Key/Shift Supervisor – Blue Moon Pizza
Join a Brand with Roots—and a Bold New Future!
Blue Moon Pizza has been serving up unforgettable food and neighborhood vibes for over 20 years. What started as a single pizzeria has grown into a local favorite. Now, under energized new leadership and ambitious growth plans, we’re on the cusp of becoming something even greater—a regional powerhouse that never forgets its roots.
We're looking for Store Key/Shift Supervisors who want more than just a job—they want to grow with the brand. If you’re passionate about hospitality, thrive in a team-driven environment, and are excited by the idea of helping shape the next great restaurant chain, Blue Moon Pizza could be your next home.
Why Blue Moon Pizza?
We offer the best of both worlds: the close-knit feel of a local favorite and the career growth of a rising brand.
- Competitive pay s
- Health & dental insurance
- Paid time off (PTO)
- Flexible schedules
- Employee discounts (our pizza really is that good)
- Growth opportunities as we expand—we prioritize promoting from within
- A familial atmosphere built on respect, teamwork, and positivity
- The excitement of being part of a brand on the rise, with real room to grow your career
What You’ll Do
As a Key Supervisor, you’ll support the management team in driving smooth operations, strong team morale, and standout guest experiences. You’ll lead by example, handle the day-to-day rhythm of the store, and be a trusted right-hand leader.
You will:
- Help run high-energy shifts across dine-in, takeout, delivery, and third-party platforms
- Lead with hospitality—meeting guests, creating great dining experiences, and encouraging your team to do the same
- Jump in across all roles, whether prepping food, assisting service, or resolving challenges
- Keep the store clean, organized, and efficient—every shift, every day
- Help with scheduling, training, and holding staff to high standards
- Support cost control and labor tracking efforts
- Contribute to local store marketing and brand building
- Use social media tools and trends to promote the store and drive engagement
- Be part of a leadership team helping guide the store—and the brand—into its next chapter
What You Bring
- 1+ year of leadership experience in a fast-paced restaurant, bar, or foodservice environment
- A guest-first mindset and natural ability to connect with people
- A desire to be part of something growing—to learn, take on more, and rise as the brand expands
- Familiarity with social media platforms and how restaurants use them to build community
- Flexibility to work varied shifts, including nights, weekends, and holidays
- Solid operational and organizational skills
- A positive, accountable attitude and a willingness to lead by example
- A belief in our North Star values and in helping us build a restaurant chain that never loses its soul
Ready to Grow with a Brand That’s Growing?
If you want to be part of a team where your voice matters, your energy is valued, and your future is full of possibility, this is your chance. Blue Moon Pizza isn’t just a restaurant—it’s a place where careers can take off.
To apply, please submit:
- Your resume (including relevant experience and salary expectations)
We are an equal opportunity employer and all qualified applicants will receive consideration for employment without regard to race, color, religion, sex, national origin, disability status, protected veteran status, or any other characteristic protected by law.
Blue Moon Pizza Careers and Jobs
An everyday place that feels special.
When Blue Moon Pizza opened in 2003, the basic idea was simple: Give people an everyday place that feels special. And for that, you need the right ingredients. It starts with authentic, made-to-order, top-notch food, amazing people, and a one-of-a-kind atmosphere all at prices that won’t break the bank. And, of course, don’t forget our full-service bar!
Pizza is the perfect signature item. It’s a sharing food everybody loves. And with a pinch of this and a dash of that, you can make it exactly the way your taste buds crave it.
Now, when we look around and hear what our regular guests and team members say, we realize that Blue Moon turned out to be a special place, for your everyday. So join us and come be part of the Blue Moon Pizza family.
Life Should Be Less Ordinary!
What is it like to work at Blue Moon Pizza?
Blue Moon Pizza is a fast-paced, full-service restaurant. We have a "sleeves up" approach, which means all team members help each other out, no matter what the role. We work hard and look for every opportunity to provide exceptional service to our guests while making memories one slice at a time.
What are the perks and benefits of working at Blue Moon Pizza?
We offer health insurance for all full-time team members and leadership. Discounted meals. A flexible work schedule. A high-paced fun atmosphere. Growth opportunities. Food you can be proud to prepare and serve.
What does career growth look like at Blue Moon Pizza?
Blue Moon believes that promoting from within is the best way to keep our culture alive and give the hard-working team members who helped grow the culture the chance to move into leadership positions either in their home restaurants or move to another location.