We are sharing a specialised part-time consulting opportunity for experienced in-house legal professionals with at least five years of experience practising in Australia and strong expertise in Australian commercial and contract law.
This role supports a legal AI evaluation initiative focused on assessing how accurately advanced AI systems answer real-world questions involving Australian law. Selected professionals will compare responses generated by two AI platforms, score them against a standardised rubric, and provide concise written feedback grounded in professional legal judgment.
Key Responsibilities
Australian Legal Analysis
- Review AI-generated responses to realistic questions involving Australian law
- Assess legal accuracy, completeness, reasoning quality, and practical relevance
- Apply experienced in-house counsel judgment to commercial and contractual matters
- Identify incorrect legal conclusions, missing considerations, and unsupported reasoning
- Evaluate whether responses appropriately reflect Australian legal practice
AI Response Comparison
- Run identical legal prompts across two AI platforms
- Compare responses side by side using consistent evaluation criteria
- Identify meaningful differences in legal reasoning, accuracy, and usefulness
- Determine which response more effectively addresses the underlying legal question
- Flag errors or omissions that could materially affect legal decision-making
Scoring & Evaluation
- Score each response against a provided standardised rubric
- Apply evaluation criteria consistently across assignments
- Distinguish substantive legal weaknesses from minor presentation issues
- Ensure scores reflect both legal accuracy and practical usefulness
- Maintain rigorous and defensible evaluation standards
Written Legal Feedback
- Provide concise written justification for each evaluation
- Explain significant legal errors, omissions, or reasoning weaknesses clearly
- Document relevant differences between competing AI responses
- Communicate findings precisely in written English
- Complete assigned evaluations according to project deadlines
Ideal Profile
Strong candidates may have:
- At least 5 years of professional experience as in-house legal counsel practising in Australia
- Strong command of Australian law
- Substantial experience with commercial and contract matters
- Experience advising businesses on practical legal issues
- Strong ability to evaluate complex legal reasoning
- Excellent written English and attention to detail
- Ability to work independently using structured evaluation criteria
- Strong professional judgment and consistency when reviewing legal work
Educational Background
- A legal degree or equivalent professional legal qualification is highly relevant
- Professional qualifications appropriate to legal practice in Australia may strengthen an application
- Substantial professional experience involving Australian commercial and contract law is particularly important for this engagement
Nice to Have
- Experience reviewing legal research or analysis produced by other professionals
- Background advising multinational or complex commercial organisations
- Experience with technology, software, or AI-related legal matters
- Familiarity with legal research or legal technology platforms
- Prior experience with rubric-based legal review or structured evaluation
- Experience evaluating AI-generated legal content
Why This Opportunity
- Apply Australian legal expertise to advanced legal AI evaluation
- Review realistic questions grounded in commercial and contract practice
- Compare the performance of multiple AI systems using professional legal judgment
- Help improve the accuracy and reliability of AI-generated legal analysis
- Participate in a focused remote engagement with competitive hourly compensation
- Potential for additional work following the initial project scope
Contract Details
- Independent contractor role
- Fully remote with flexible scheduling
- At least 5 years of in-house legal experience practising in Australia is required
- Initial commitment of approximately 10 hours, with strong potential for additional work
- Competitive rates between $95–$115 per hour depending on expertise and project scope
- Work may include AI response comparison, Australian legal analysis, rubric-based scoring, and written evaluation
- All project work is subject to confidentiality requirements and NDA
- Weekly payments via Stripe or Wise
- Projects may be extended, shortened, or adjusted depending on scope and performance
- Work will not involve access to confidential or proprietary information from any employer, client, or institution
About the Platform
This opportunity is available through 24-MAG LLC. We connect experienced professionals with remote consulting opportunities across technical, evaluation, and project-based workstreams.
By submitting this application, you acknowledge that your information may be processed by 24-MAG LLC for recruitment and opportunity matching in accordance with our Privacy Policy: https://www.24-mag.com/privacy-policy.