Declining a job offer can sometimes be a smart move for your career
Check out these nine telltale signs that a company is terrible to work for, and why saying no to an offer could be your best bet.
Rejecting a job offer may seem nuts to eager seekers, but sometimes, it’s really the smartest thing to do. Fact: Some companies are just a nightmare to work for. A bad boss, poor leadership, and limited opportunities for advancement are just a few reasons why. And when you hate your job and dread going to work every day, your performance can suffer—and your career can stall. Declining a job offer from such a miserable company is, in fact, a wise move.
The good news is that there are warning signs you can look for during the hiring process that will suggest the company is a hot mess.
“Job interviewing is like dating. If there are too many red flags, it’s not going to be the right fit,” says Stamford, Connecticut–based executive coach Anne Marie Segal.
Of course, spotting one or two of these signs doesn’t necessarily mean you should turn down a job offer, but if you see these signs piling up, it should set off alarm bells.
1. The company has a bad reputation
These days, few job seekers jump into the process without reading company reviews, and with good reason—people are more than willing to air grievances online. According to a recent Monster poll, the majority (38%) of U.S. respondents said, based on a five-star rating system, a company should have at least a three-star rating to be considered good enough to apply to. Do your homework and find out how current and past employees feel about working there. Check out company reviews on Monster or kununu to see what’s being said about your prospective employer.
Again, one or two negative reviews isn’t cause for concern—chances are good there will be a couple disgruntled employees, and, as 27% of Monster poll respondents pointed out, just because other people were unhappy, doesn’t necessarily mean you will be. Still, you should be looking for patterns, advises Chrissy Scivicque, career coach and founder of EatYourCareer.com. “If everyone’s saying the organization is disorganized or leadership is lacking, it’s something to take to heart,” she says.
2. The communication is sorely lacking
Do your emails and phone calls to the hiring manager or recruiter consistently go unreturned? Does it seem like the people who work there don’t know much about what’s going on? That kind of poor communication could indicate the company is disorganized as a whole.
Employers should have open and active lines of communication with their prospective hires. “You shouldn’t feel ghosted at any point during the hiring process,” Segal says.
Unprofessional correspondence is also a red flag. An interested company should make you, a prospective employee, feel welcome, treating you with courtesy and respect throughout the hiring process, says Hallie Crawford, a career coach in Atlanta.
3. The job duties are unclear
Ideally, a job posting clearly outlines the responsibilities of the position—the operative word is ideally. “A lot of hiring managers and recruiters don’t know how to write job descriptions,” says Segal.
If that’s the case, your best approach is to ask the recruiter or hiring manager directly, “What are the main components of the job? What would I be doing on a daily basis?”
Can’t get a straight answer? Look for another job. “If there is no clear definition of the role and no criteria for measuring performance,” Crawford says, “you won’t be able to succeed in the position.”
4. Employees seem unhappy
When you go in for an interview, read the room. Are employees smiling, or is there a sea of sad, discouraged faces? If a single visit to an office is depressing, you wouldn’t want to work in that type of atmosphere day in and day out.
5. The office is a mess
“If you want to work with a mad scientist, maybe a messy office isn’t a warning sign for you,” Segal says. But, in general, if you see cubicles overflowing with clutter or trash piling up, that’s an issue—especially if you’re the type of person who needs a clean, organized work environment to be able to focus on your work.
6. The hiring manager pulls a bait-and-switch
Here’s as clear a red flag as you can find: You’re called in to interview for a position, but when you arrive at the office, the interviewer says, “Oh, that position has just been filled, but we have another job we think you’d be a great fit for.”
In most cases, says Scivicque, “that’s a sign that the employer is operating on bad faith.” This is even bigger red flag if the new position pays less than the job you applied for. In other words, if you inquire about a convertible, you expect to be shown a convertible, not an electric scooter.
7. The employer asks you to do work for free
Depending on the position to which you’re applying, it’s not unusual to have to complete preliminary assignments as part of the interview process. For example, submitting writing samples may be part of an application for an editorial position.
But if a hiring manager asks you to do a significant amount of contract work to see if you’re right for the position, the company should be paying you for the time you put in. “No reputable organization should be asking you to do free work as part of your audition for the position,” Scivicque says.
8. The boss seems like trouble
A bad manager can make even a dream job a nightmare. Therefore, during the interview process, it’s important to look out for warning signs of a toxic boss.
Even if the boss seems benign on the toxicity scale, you have to evaluate their personality and work style to determine how well you’d do reporting to that person. “If you feel like your communication styles are very different—maybe the manager is assertive and you’re more laid back—that could be an issue for you if you take the job,” Crawford adds.
9. You feel pressured into taking the offer
Bottom line: Don’t be afraid to turn down a job offer. In the hiring process, recruiters and managers often rely on their gut when making decisions about candidates. Trust your gut, too. If it doesn't feel right, play it smart and look for another job. Need some help with that? Join Monster for free today. As a member, you can upload up to five versions of your resume—each tailored to the types of jobs that interest you. Recruiters search Monster every day looking to fill top jobs with qualified candidates, just like you. Additionally, you can get job alerts sent to you when positions become available. Monster can help you go from rejecting to rejoicing in job offers.