NewProject Manager JobotProject ManagerTempe, AZ$130,000–$155,000 / yearJoin a company where you'll lead impactful commercial projects, work alongside exceptional construction professionals, and have a clear path toward Senior Project Management as the organization continues its impressive growth across Arizona. Information collected and processed as part of your Jobot candidate profile, and any job applications, resumes, or other information you choose to submit is subject to Jobot's Privacy Policy, as well as the Jobot California Worker Privacy Notice and Jobot Notice Regarding Automated Employment Decision Tools which are available at jobot.com/legal.
NewConstruction Risk and Contracts Manager JobotConstruction Risk and Contracts ManagerTempe, AZ$150,000–$190,000 / yearThis role serves as a trusted business partner to Operations, Project Management, Preconstruction, Finance, Legal Counsel, insurance brokers, and surety partners to ensure projects are delivered while effectively managing contractual and financial risk. Lead enterprise-wide risk strategy for one of Arizona's fastest-growing commercial contractors—partner directly with executive leadership, build best-in-class processes, and make a lasting impact on the future of the business.
NewSenior Project Manager JobotSenior Project ManagerTempe, AZ$150,000–$200,000 / yearInformation collected and processed as part of your Jobot candidate profile, and any job applications, resumes, or other information you choose to submit is subject to Jobot's Privacy Policy, as well as the Jobot California Worker Privacy Notice and Jobot Notice Regarding Automated Employment Decision Tools which are available at jobot.com/legal. Lead landmark commercial projects, mentor high-performing teams, and become a key contributor to a company whose reputation has been built almost entirely through repeat clients and referrals.
NewPartner JobotPartnerApache Junction, AZRemote$160,000–$200,000 / yearInformation collected and processed as part of your Jobot candidate profile, and any job applications, resumes, or other information you choose to submit is subject to Jobot's Privacy Policy, as well as the Jobot California Worker Privacy Notice and Jobot Notice Regarding Automated Employment Decision Tools which are available at jobot.com/legal. By applying for this job, you agree to receive calls, AI-generated calls, text messages, or emails from Jobot, and/or its agents and contracted partners.
NewBIM Manager JobotBIM ManagerPhoenix, AZ$125,000–$150,000 / yearInformation collected and processed as part of your Jobot candidate profile, and any job applications, resumes, or other information you choose to submit is subject to Jobot's Privacy Policy, as well as the Jobot California Worker Privacy Notice and Jobot Notice Regarding Automated Employment Decision Tools which are available at jobot.com/legal. Our client is seeking an experienced BIM Manager to lead the implementation, coordination, and management of Building Information Modeling (BIM) processes across multiple projects.
NewPreconstruction Director JobotPreconstruction DirectorPhoenix, AZ$150,000–$190,000 / yearInformation collected and processed as part of your Jobot candidate profile, and any job applications, resumes, or other information you choose to submit is subject to Jobot's Privacy Policy, as well as the Jobot California Worker Privacy Notice and Jobot Notice Regarding Automated Employment Decision Tools which are available at jobot.com/legal. As a self-performing contractor, we manage every critical scope — from earthwork and concrete to underground utilities and mechanical systems — ensuring precision, efficiency, and unmatched project delivery.
NewDirector of Safety - Commercial Roofing JobotDirector of Safety - Commercial RoofingPhoenix, AZ$140,000–$160,000 / yearInformation collected and processed as part of your Jobot candidate profile, and any job applications, resumes, or other information you choose to submit is subject to Jobot's Privacy Policy, as well as the Jobot California Worker Privacy Notice and Jobot Notice Regarding Automated Employment Decision Tools which are available at jobot.com/legal. This person is not expected to build a program from the ground up—but rather bring leadership, accountability, process improvement, and field presence to elevate performance and ensure consistent execution.
NewHeavy Civil Preconstruction Manager JobotHeavy Civil Preconstruction ManagerPhoenix, AZ$150,000–$190,000 / yearInformation collected and processed as part of your Jobot candidate profile, and any job applications, resumes, or other information you choose to submit is subject to Jobot's Privacy Policy, as well as the Jobot California Worker Privacy Notice and Jobot Notice Regarding Automated Employment Decision Tools which are available at jobot.com/legal. For immediate response, please email resume/projects directly to: https://jobot.com/apply/heavy-civil-preconstruction-manager/589490994?utm_source=Monster.
NewArchitectural Project Associate JobotArchitectural Project AssociatePhoenix, AZ$55,000–$65,000 / yearInformation collected and processed as part of your Jobot candidate profile, and any job applications, resumes, or other information you choose to submit is subject to Jobot's Privacy Policy, as well as the Jobot California Worker Privacy Notice and Jobot Notice Regarding Automated Employment Decision Tools which are available at jobot.com/legal. Here are some of the experience we are looking for: putting together full sets of CDs, permitting, RFIs, and site visits for upfront verification, during construction, punch-lists, and meeting with the city for permit related requirements.
NewArchitectural Project Manager JobotArchitectural Project ManagerPhoenix, AZ$75,000–$90,000 / yearInformation collected and processed as part of your Jobot candidate profile, and any job applications, resumes, or other information you choose to submit is subject to Jobot's Privacy Policy, as well as the Jobot California Worker Privacy Notice and Jobot Notice Regarding Automated Employment Decision Tools which are available at jobot.com/legal. Here are some of the experience we are looking for: putting together full sets of CDs, permitting, RFIs, and site visits for upfront verification, during construction, punch-lists, and meeting with the city for permit related requirements.
NewMechanical Project Manager JobotMechanical Project ManagerPhoenix, AZ$135,000–$190,000 / yearInformation collected and processed as part of your Jobot candidate profile, and any job applications, resumes, or other information you choose to submit is subject to Jobot's Privacy Policy, as well as the Jobot California Worker Privacy Notice and Jobot Notice Regarding Automated Employment Decision Tools which are available at jobot.com/legal. Our teams support technically demanding projects across healthcare, commercial, and institutional markets, partnering closely with clients to deliver high-quality, efficient solutions.
NewProject Manager (Data Center Construction) JobotProject Manager (Data Center Construction)Phoenix, AZ$130,000–$200,000 / yearInformation collected and processed as part of your Jobot candidate profile, and any job applications, resumes, or other information you choose to submit is subject to Jobot's Privacy Policy, as well as the Jobot California Worker Privacy Notice and Jobot Notice Regarding Automated Employment Decision Tools which are available at jobot.com/legal. By applying for this job, you agree to receive calls, AI-generated calls, text messages, or emails from Jobot, and/or its agents and contracted partners.
NewTraffic Project Manager JobotTraffic Project ManagerTempe, AZ$135,000–$170,000 / yearInformation collected and processed as part of your Jobot candidate profile, and any job applications, resumes, or other information you choose to submit is subject to Jobot's Privacy Policy, as well as the Jobot California Worker Privacy Notice and Jobot Notice Regarding Automated Employment Decision Tools which are available at jobot.com/legal. A client with 50 years of industry experience is looking to bring on a new team member that is specialized in traffic engineering, with a knack for traffic design, signaling, operations, and analysis.
NewSite Supervisor - Commercial Landscaping JobotSite Supervisor - Commercial LandscapingPhoenix, AZ$70,000–$100,000 / yearInformation collected and processed as part of your Jobot candidate profile, and any job applications, resumes, or other information you choose to submit is subject to Jobot's Privacy Policy, as well as the Jobot California Worker Privacy Notice and Jobot Notice Regarding Automated Employment Decision Tools which are available at jobot.com/legal. In this hands-on role you will manage daily field operations, supervise crews, ensure quality and safety, communicate with clients and office staff, and help deliver projects on time and on budget.
NewBridge Project Manager JobotBridge Project ManagerPhoenix, AZ$135,000–$160,000 / yearInformation collected and processed as part of your Jobot candidate profile, and any job applications, resumes, or other information you choose to submit is subject to Jobot's Privacy Policy, as well as the Jobot California Worker Privacy Notice and Jobot Notice Regarding Automated Employment Decision Tools which are available at jobot.com/legal. A well-known firm with over 40 years of bridge structural experience is looking to bring on a talented Bridge Project Manager to oversee their almost $50million dollar design project.
NewHeavy Civil/Industrial Project Manager - Water/Wastewater JobotHeavy Civil/Industrial Project Manager - Water/WastewaterPhoenix, AZ$120,000–$150,000 / year2. Proven experience in managing water and wastewater construction projects, including experience with underground utilities, pump stations, site work, structural concrete, - knowledge of process piping, mechanical piping, and yard piping a plus! Information collected and processed as part of your Jobot candidate profile, and any job applications, resumes, or other information you choose to submit is subject to Jobot's Privacy Policy, as well as the Jobot California Worker Privacy Notice and Jobot Notice Regarding Automated Employment Decision Tools which are available at jobot.com/legal.
NewProject Manager-HVAC JobotProject Manager-HVACPhoenix, AZ$120,000–$160,000 / yearInformation collected and processed as part of your Jobot candidate profile, and any job applications, resumes, or other information you choose to submit is subject to Jobot's Privacy Policy, as well as the Jobot California Worker Privacy Notice and Jobot Notice Regarding Automated Employment Decision Tools which are available at jobot.com/legal. This role requires a hands-on approach, with the Project Manager being involved in all stages of the project, from initial planning and design, through to completion and handover.
NewDigital Product Owner Vaco LLCDigital Product OwnerTempe, AZ$55–$70This role sits at the center of a rapidly scaling digital ecosystem - owning backlog, driving roadmap execution, and partnering closely with stakeholders to deliver best-in-class customer experiences across platforms like mobile ordering, loyalty, and digital engagement. Determining compensation for this role (and others) at Vaco by Highspring depends upon a wide array of factors including but not limited to: the individual’s skill sets, experience and training; licensure and certification requirements; office location and other geographic considerations; other business and organizational needs.
NewContract Executive Assistant! Vaco LLCContract Executive Assistant!Phoenix, AZ$28–$35Determining compensation for this role (and others) at Vaco by Highspring depends upon a wide array of factors including but not limited to: the individual’s skill sets, experience and training; licensure and certification requirements; office location and other geographic considerations; other business and organizational needs. Determining compensation for this role (and others) at Vaco/Highspring depends upon a wide array of factors including but not limited to the individual’s skill sets, experience and training, licensure and certifications, office location and other geographic considerations, as well as other business and organizational needs.
NewLead Development Representative - Outbound B2B - Hybrid TTECLead Development Representative - Outbound B2B - HybridTempe, AZIn this role, you'll engage in warm leads contact through outbound consultation with small business clients and working closely with a sales team who will present solutions that save customers time and money, enabling them to focus on what matters most. Whether it’s entering each consultation with curiosity or getting answers for customers quickly, consulting on products with compassion and a smile, you’ll be the difference between their customer experience being just average or an exceptional one.
NewPart Time Personal Trainer THE DESERT HIGHLANDS ASSOCIATIONPart Time Personal TrainerScottsdale, AZThis role is ideal for an energetic, service-focused fitness professional who enjoys building relationships, fostering a positive environment, and helping others achieve lasting results while delivering the high level of service our members expect. Desert Highlands has been recognized as a Five-Star Platinum Club, ranked as #11 in the top 100 Golf Clubs, a Distinguished Emerald Club and one of America's Healthiest Clubs.
NewTeam Manager Panera BreadTeam ManagerPhoenix, AZBe an ambassador of our Guiding Values and Behaviors by making people smile, learning and growing together, finding solutions and taking initiative, working (and winning) as a team, having fun and celebrating success, and seeing the best in others! Lead, manager and develop team members by coaching, inspiring, and motivating them to exceed goals in sales, speed, order accuracy, and guest experience – and celebrate their achievements along the way.
NewMaintenance Tech I - Contract TalentBurst, Inc.Maintenance Tech I - ContractChandler, AZ$40–$40 / hourBearing pullers, vacuum pumps, coil winders, thermocouples, two-way radios, various measuring and testing equipment such as thermometers, micrometers, voltmeters, ammeters, frequency meters, pyrometers, psychrometers, gas analyzer, signal generators, oscilloscopes, vibration analyzers, ultrasonic testers, infrared equipment, and other special recording and alignment equipment. Tools and Equipment UsedVarious poser and manual hand tools common to the trade, saws, drill presses, sanders, lathes, threading machines, pipe benders, soldering, brazing, welding, and cutting equipment, mechanical taping equipment.
Fraud Operations Associate CornerStone StaffingFraud Operations AssociateTempe, AZInvestigate and assess fraud risk across customer onboarding, transaction activity, and login flows; apply appropriate risk mitigation actions based on findings. By applying for this job, you agree to receive calls, AI-generated calls, text messages, or emails from CornerStone and its affiliates, and contracted partners.
Technical Supervisor (Blood Bank) - Banner Desert Sonora Quest LaboratoriesTechnical Supervisor (Blood Bank) - Banner DesertMesa, AZ3. Under the direction of management, ensures area(s) of responsibility are maintained in accreditation with College of American Pathologists (CAP), Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS), American Association of Blood Banks (AABB), Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and licensing for Clinical Laboratory Improvement Amendments (CLIA) for patient care and nursing. Establishes priorities, workloads, schedules, controls, work procedures and day-to-day problem resolution and trouble shooting utilizing Six Sigma and Lean concepts, tools and methodology in the department.
NewPermit/ROW Manager (Right of Way) Pinnacle Technical ResourcesPermit/ROW Manager (Right of Way)Phoenix, ArizonaContractorThis role ensures timely submission, tracking, approval, and closeout of permits across multiple jurisdictions while coordinating with internal teams, vendors, and municipal agencies to deliver projects on time and within budget. Develop and maintain strong working relationships with municipalities, including Code Enforcement, Building Inspectors, City Councils, Planning & Zoning departments, commissions, and neighborhood groups.
NewSurgical Pathology Lead - Banner Gateway Sonora Quest LaboratoriesSurgical Pathology Lead - Banner GatewayGilbert, AZThis position will be the liaison between the histology department at Papago and the hospital site surgical pathology department to assure all specimens are properly handled and triaged and that all proper documentation is completed. This position will coordinate the efforts of the site surgical pathology assistants and assist the AP Production Manager and AP Technical Specialists in assuring all tasks are performed appropriately.
NewTechnical Supervisor - Night Shift Sonora Quest LaboratoriesTechnical Supervisor - Night ShiftPhoenix, AZ3. Under the direction of management, ensures area(s) of responsibility are maintained in accreditation with College of American Pathologists (CAP), Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS), American Association of Blood Banks (AABB), Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and licensing for Clinical Laboratory Improvement Amendments (CLIA) for patient care and nursing. Establishes priorities, workloads, schedules, controls, work procedures and day-to-day problem resolution and trouble shooting utilizing Six Sigma and Lean concepts, tools and methodology in the department.
NewBusiness Operations Specialist QwaltecBusiness Operations SpecialistTempe, AZThis role goes beyond traditional administrative duties and is designed for a candidate with a business degree or equivalent experience who can contribute across multiple corporate functions including executive support, accounting, finance, human resources, recruiting, contracts, and business development. Provide cross-functional support to core business areas including accounting, finance, human resources, recruiting, contracts administration, and proposal/business development activities.
NewSenior Finance and Accounting Manager – Government Contracting DCAA/FAR Compliance QwaltecSenior Finance and Accounting Manager – Government Contracting DCAA/FAR ComplianceTempe, AZCandidates must have deep experience in maximizing profit, budgeting, accounting, and analysis for government services businesses, demonstrated ability to collaborate cross-functionally, exemplary organizational and time-management skills, excellent verbal and written communication skills, and a strong drive to support company growth. Demonstrated success facilitating financial compliance and positive audit results and working on cross-functional teams to support executives leading business operations, growth, strategy, and partnerships (COO, VP for Growth and Strategy, and CEO).
NewHeat Treat Lead Operator Davron LLCHeat Treat Lead OperatorPhoenix, AZHEAT TREAT OPERATOR - LEAD | 2ND SHIFT | 3RD SHIFT | BATCH FURNACE | ENDOTHERMIC GAS | OSHA TRAINING | MTI TRAINING | IQ BATCH FURNACE | SUPERSYSTEMS INC | EXCEL | WORD | SAFETY-SENSITIVE POSITION. Heat Treat Operator - Lead offers the chance to lead batch furnace operations on 2nd or 3rd shift while helping drive consistent production and strong product quality.
NewLead Supervisor TTDT EnterprisesLead SupervisorPhoenix, AZToday, from our 5,000 square-foot National Command Center, our team delivers real-time surveillance solutions 24/7/365, offering our customers peace of mind knowing we are the “Eye in the Sky,” always watching, listening and taking action! Your supervisor team oversee a team of monitoring specialist, monitoring a variety of systems throughout the U.S., analyzing live surveillance footage and responding to potential security threats from our National Command Center.
NewChemical Delivery Design Manager Foresight TechnologiesChemical Delivery Design ManagerTempe, AZDescription:Foresight On-Site is seeking a highly experienced and technically strong Chemical Delivery Design Manager to lead the development, design, quoting, and execution of complex chemical and fluid-delivery equipment systems for high-tech and semiconductor-related manufacturing environments. The ideal candidate will bring deep expertise in chemical process equipment, strong engineering leadership, advanced technical/computer skills, and the ability to build scalable systems, teams, and processes that support rapid organizational growth.
BIM Coordinator - AZ M-ENGINEERINGBIM Coordinator - AZPhoenix, AZFull timeThe engineering services we offer are Structural, Industrial, Mechanical (Fire Protection, Plumbing & HVAC), Electrical (Lighting, Power & Fire Alarm) and Technology design disciplines. Along with offering great opportunities for advancement, M-Engineering offers its prospective associates competitive salaries, a quarterly bonus program, medical plan, as well as voluntary vision & dental plan.
Commercial Construction Assistant Project Manager HITT ContractingCommercial Construction Assistant Project ManagerPhoenix, AZFull timeGather data, interpret it into meaningful information, and relay that information through clear, concise communication strategies; ability to see how pieces and processes fit into and affect the bigger picture/business model. An Assistant Project Manager (APM) obtains, evaluates, coordinates and distributes the information and authorizations necessary to construct projects on time, within budget and to the quality specified.
NewPeople & Culture Manager, Meeting Planning bdo consultingPeople & Culture Manager, Meeting PlanningPhoenix, AZ$60,000–$85,000 / yearCoordinates and monitors event activities to ensure compliance with firm guidelines, applicable regulations and laws, and satisfaction of internal clients, including selection of venues, hotel accommodations, air travel, ground transportation, catering, signage, technology, special needs, and onsite meeting support. The People & Culture Meeting Planning Manager is responsible for the planning and administration of firm-sponsored events and meetings that require development of event budgets, contract negotiation with service providers and suppliers, and on-site event management.
NewDAS Project Manager- AZ Communication Technology Services IncDAS Project Manager- AZPhoenix, AZ$80,000–$120,000 / yearA successful PM in this role drives projects toward an ideal outcome: an elated customer satisfied with communication, delivery, and coverage, zero safety incidents, high quality installation, delivery ahead of the schedule, in-line with quoted profit, clean change order management, and a tech team that comes out of the project stronger than before. Communication Technology Services (CTS) is one of the largest integrators and managed service providers for enterprise cellular networks in the U.S., specializing in the design, installation, and support of Distributed Antenna Systems (DAS), Small Cell, ERRCS, and 4G/5G Private Wireless Networks for Enterprise.
Internal Medicine Leadership Position in Phoenix, Arizona CHG HealthcareInternal Medicine Leadership Position in Phoenix, ArizonaPhoenix, AZThe city's warm climate, lower cost of living compared to other major cities, and outdoor recreational activities make it an attractive place to settle. Phoenix, AZ, is an excellent place for physicians to live and practice due to its booming healthcare industry, diverse patient population, and high demand for medical professionals.
NewField Supervision Director – Annuity Edward Jones InvestmentsField Supervision Director – AnnuityTempe, AZEdward Jones’ compensation and benefits package includes medical and prescription drug, dental, vision, voluntary benefits (such as accident, hospital indemnity, and critical illness), short- and long-term disability, basic life, and basic AD&D coverage. • Extensive knowledge of various annuity products including variable annuities, fixed annuities, indexed annuities, single premium immediate annuities, and deferred income annuities.
NewSenior Director – Experienced Advisor Acquisition Edward Jones InvestmentsSenior Director – Experienced Advisor AcquisitionTempe, AZThis role partners closely with senior leadership, Finance, Business HR, and field leadership to anticipate workforce needs, build proactive pipelines, and deliver a best-in-class candidate experience. The Senior Director, Experienced Advisor Acquisition provides strategic leadership for the firm’s advisor and client-facing talent attraction efforts, ensuring the acquisition of high-quality, growth-oriented professionals aligned with firm values and long-term objectives.
NewSourcing Manager (Contract Negotiator) Edward Jones InvestmentsSourcing Manager (Contract Negotiator)Tempe, AZThis particular role will work primarily on professional services efforts across the firm, including areas like contingent workforce, delivery and implementation work, consulting, managed services, and business process outsourcing. • Execute on defined objectives aligned to Sourcing Strategies through the development and distribution of RFx’s (RFI, RFQ, RFP), vendor communication, development of vendor selection criteria, and collaboration with cross-functional teams including business owners and legal.
NewService Director- Larry H. Miller Ford Mesa Asbury Automotive GroupService Director- Larry H. Miller Ford MesaMesa, AZLarry H Miller Automotive Group is part of Asbury Automotive Group (NYSE: ABG) is a Fortune 500 company and one of the largest franchised automotive retailers in the United States. At Asbury, we work together to provide exceptional experiences for our guests while promoting a fun, supportive and inclusive environment where team members can thrive both personally and professionally.
NewSenior Planner - High Net Worth Edward Jones InvestmentsSenior Planner - High Net WorthTempe, AZThe Edward Jones Generations™ team provides an end-to-end, high net worth (HNW) client experience by partnering with our branch teams to provide ongoing client services including holistic financial planning, tax and estate planning services via trusted 3rd parties, plan implementation via expanding sets of Edward Jones products and services, and ongoing reporting and support. • Act as an advanced subject matter expert in Financial Planning, Discovery, and a broad range of other areas of client specific emphasis, understand broad market opportunities and how they translate to strategic initiatives within various business areas to identify, create, and develop the most advanced client focused business building ideas to meet the most complex needs.
NewLifestyle Director CCMCLifestyle DirectorGlendale, AZIf driving is, or becomes, a requirement of the role, it is required, at all times, that you hold a valid state driver’s license for the class of vehicle you are driving, maintain a clean motor vehicle report, and hold current automobile insurance at statutory limits. Prominently situated among the most elevated and mountainous land in the area, this community features stunning panoramic views, natural desert foothills, and dramatic dark skies.
NewSenior Vice President - Community Management CCMCSenior Vice President - Community ManagementScottsdale, AZLeadership Credibility: A highly involved and engaged leader who communicates directly and appropriately throughout the organization and with all external audiences, using fact-based decision-making as a tool to build consensus. Serves in a market leadership capacity within the Community Association Institute (CAI) and Urban Land Institute (ULI), and represents CCMC at industry events to support community association involvement and business development.
ASSISTANT DIRECTOR - CONTRACT ADMINISTRATION Arizona State UniversityASSISTANT DIRECTOR - CONTRACT ADMINISTRATIONTempe, AZ$106,000–$110,000 / yearFull timeThis position will oversee a diverse portfolio of service contracts that support university campus operations, which include janitorial services, Educational Outreach and Student Services (EOSS) Support, elevators, waste and recycling programs, and other assigned contracted services. Bachelor's degree and five (5) years of experience appropriate to the area of assignment/field including two (2) years managerial experience; OR, Any equivalent combination of experience and/or training from which comparable knowledge, skills and abilities have been achieved.
Construction Contracts Manager – Capital Programs Management Group Arizona State UniversityConstruction Contracts Manager – Capital Programs Management GroupTempe, AZ$80,000–$90,000 / yearFull timeFacilities Development and Management, Capital Planning Services, seeks a Construction Contracts Manager to provide centralized expertise, compliance oversight, contract administration support, and training for construction-related procurement and contracting activities. Bachelor's degree and three (3) years of experience appropriate to the area of assignment/field; OR, Any equivalent combination of experience and/or training from which comparable knowledge, skills and abilities have been achieved.
Assistant Director – Project Turn Over & Building Performance / Capital Programs Management Group Arizona State UniversityAssistant Director – Project Turn Over & Building Performance / Capital Programs Management GroupTempe, AZ$100,000–$110,000 / yearFull timeThe Assistant Director provides leadership and oversight for commissioning, quality assurance, and quality control (QA/QC), project closeout, warranty management, turnover readiness, and LEED certification activities across ASU's capital construction portfolio. Bachelor's degree and five (5) years of experience appropriate to the area of assignment/field including two (2) years managerial experience; OR, Any equivalent combination of experience and/or training from which comparable knowledge, skills and abilities have been achieved.