Asset LivingNewMaintenance Technician Asset LivingMaintenance TechnicianBuffalo, NY$20–$23 / hourin all directions, lifting and placing objects of 100+ lbs., communicate with others to exchange information, repeat motions that may include wrists, hands and/or fingers, operate machinery and power tools, operate motor vehicles and/or golf carts, assess the accuracy, neatness, and thoroughness of the work assigned, identify and inspect objects and areas, exposed to outdoor weather elements (wind, precipitation) including low and high temperatures and exposed to hazardous chemicals, and able to work overtime, weekends, night hours (on-call property emergencies). The employee is frequently required to ascend and descend ladders, stairs, ramps, step stools, etc., move self in different positions to accomplish tasks in various environments, including tight and confined spaces, traverse flat and uneven terrain, work in an overhead position and/or reaching, adjust or move objects of 100+ lbs.
Asset LivingNewMaintenance Supervisor Asset LivingMaintenance SupervisorOswego, NY$28–$32 / hourThe employee is frequently required to move self into different positions to accomplish tasks in various environments, including tight and confined spaces, ascend and descend stairs, ladders, ramps, step stools, etc., traverse flat and uneven terrain, work in an overhead position and/or reach, use wrists, hands and fingers in repeating motions, operate machinery and power tools, operate motor vehicles and/or golf carts, exposed to outdoor weather elements (wind, precipitation) including low and high temperatures and exposed to hazardous chemicals and be able to work overtime, weekends and night hours (on-call property emergencies). The employee is frequently required to move self into different positions to accomplish tasks in various environments, including tight and confined spaces, traverse flat and uneven terrain, ascend and descend stairs, ladders, ramps, step stools, etc., work in an overhead position and/or reach, operate machinery and power tools, operate motor vehicles and/or golf carts, adjust and move objects of 100+ lbs.
RefrescoNewMaintenance Supervisor, Nights RefrescoMaintenance Supervisor, NightsDunkirk, NY$90,000–$105,000The applicant who is hired will receive wages within the range that will be based on several factors, including, as applicable, criteria such as years and type of experience, relevant education, training, qualifications, certifications/licensing, skills, geographic location, performance, market considerations, seniority system, merit system, systems that measure earnings by quantity or quality of production, and business or organizational needs. Reporting to the Maintenance Manager, the Supervisor Maintenance is responsible for providing leadership for the maintenance functions, ensuring proper preventive maintenance of physical plant and all operating equipment, electrical troubleshooting, minimizing equipment downtime to provide maximum production capacity, and compliance with all Occupational Health and Safety regulations.
BMW Management Co. LLCApartment Maintenance Technician BMW Management Co. LLCApartment Maintenance TechnicianWilliamsville, NYWith a lower-than-average turnover rate and a true neighborhood feel, Windsong Place offers the opportunity to build meaningful connections while contributing to a community that residents—and staff—are proud to call home. Set within a beautifully maintained, park-like environment, Windsong Place has been locally owned and professionally managed for over 30 years, earning a reputation for quality, consistency, and pride in ownership.
Temple Building LlcPart Time - Apartment Maintenance Technician Temple Building LlcPart Time - Apartment Maintenance TechnicianRochester, NYWe are seeking a reliable and skilled Part-Time Maintenance Technician to support several residential properties in the Downtown area. This role is ideal for someone who is hands-on, energetic, and eager to contribute to a well‑maintained, resident‑focused environment.
GORDON MANAGEMENT COMPANY LLCApartment Maintenance Technician GORDON MANAGEMENT COMPANY LLCApartment Maintenance TechnicianGansevoort, NYAddress and resolve resident service requests in a timely, professional manner, including electrical, HVAC, plumbing, and appliance repairs, as well as carpentry and other building fixture maintenance. Prepare apartments for market readiness, including painting, drywall repair, carpentry, carpet cleaning/repair, general repairs, and housekeeping.
Burns Management CorporationApartment Turnover Technician Burns Management CorporationApartment Turnover TechnicianSaratoga Springs, NY$19–$20Responsible for all aspects related apartment turnovers and make readies, as well as the upkeep of grounds, amenities, building exteriors, leasing office, and parking lots. Inform foreman of need for additional maintenance, when applicable, in any areas where work orders or apartment turnovers are being performed.
Burns Management CorporationApartment Service Technician Burns Management CorporationApartment Service TechnicianGuilderland, NY$21–$22Service resident community by cooperating with residents, completing work orders in a timely, unobtrusive manner, and assisting cleaning staff. Responsible for all aspects related to apartment maintenance and service, as well as the upkeep of grounds, amenities, building exteriors, leasing office, and parking lots.
GORDON MANAGEMENT COMPANY LLCMultifamily Residential Maintenance Technician GORDON MANAGEMENT COMPANY LLCMultifamily Residential Maintenance TechnicianAlbany, NYAddress and resolve resident service requests in a timely, professional manner, including electrical, HVAC, plumbing, and appliance repairs, as well as carpentry and other building fixture maintenance. Prepare apartments for market readiness, including painting, drywall repair, carpentry, carpet cleaning/repair, general repairs, and housekeeping.
Titan Corp USMaintenance Technician Titan Corp USMaintenance TechnicianBellport, NY$24–$25 / hourPool maintenance is a big responsibility and often requires you to lift and / or transport 100-pound drums of granular chlorine, 50-pound drums of stick chlorine, and 50-pound bags of soda ash or bicarbonate of soda. · Our commercial laundry rooms are equipped with single washing machines and / or stacked (double) clothes dryers, which you will be required to move in order to repair and perform preventative maintenance.
Vanguard LivingMaintenance Technician (Live-in) Vanguard LivingMaintenance Technician (Live-in)Wyandanch, NYPower tools including circular saw, power drill, bench grinder, string trimmer, hedge trimmer, power floor cleaner, carpet shampoo machine, power drain cleaner, chainsaw, key machine, etc. Medium to heavy work requiring prolonged or repeated standing, walking, climbing, stooping, kneeling, crouching, and lifting to a maximum of 100 lbs., with frequent lifting and carrying up to 50 lbs.
ALLURE LIFESTYLES COMMUNITIES, LLCMaintenance Technician ALLURE LIFESTYLES COMMUNITIES, LLCMaintenance TechnicianUtica, NYSchuyler Commons is an upscale community for active adults ages 55+ where designing and fostering an exceptional lifestyle experience for our residents is at the center of everything we do. The responsibilities that are listed below are not all inclusive; however, they are indicative of the type of responsibilities normally performed by the Maintenance Technician: Completes maintenance work orders as assigned.
The Community BuildersService Maintenance Technician I The Community BuildersService Maintenance Technician IYonkers, NY$19–$21 / hourUnder the direction of the Service Maintenance Manager, the Service Maintenance Technician I is responsible for the completion of general maintenance and janitorial tasks which help to preserve the property and provides a quality living environment for the residents. This role has primary accountability for the overall cleanliness, physical appearance and presentation of the community, while maintaining a positive, productive relationship with the other team members and with residents.
Rochester's Cornerstone Group, Ltd.Maintenance Technician Rochester's Cornerstone Group, Ltd.Maintenance TechnicianBuffalo, New York$20–$24Cornerstone has also brokered dozens of commercial properties in the region, ranging from professional office space to vacant land to industrial parks, as well as developed multiple commercial properties, from new construction to historic renovation. These projects serve a wide range of people, including families, the elderly, individuals with mobility impairments or people with developmental disabilities.
Atria Senior Living - PatchogueMaintenance Technician Atria Senior Living - PatchogueMaintenance TechnicianPatchogue, New York$19–$22.80 / hourResponsibilities: Diagnose and repair problems in such areas as HVAC, electrical, plumbing, major appliances, carpentry, emergency systems, flooring, hardware accessories, masonry, painting/wallpaper, water features (pools, spas, etc.) and waste management systems. Able to frequently use general maintenance tools, supplies and equipment such as, but not limited to, hand tools, pressure washers, blowers, paint equipment, pool chemicals, ice removal equipment, ladders, landscaping equipment, sanders and safety equipment.
PeakMade Real EstateMaintenance Technician PeakMade Real EstateMaintenance TechnicianSyracuse, NY$19–$22Position requires individuals to be able to use general maintenance equipment including, but not limited to, hand tools, ladders, refrigerant recovery units, landscaping equipment, and required safety equipment . We also believe in owning our responsibility to learn more about the differences that make us stronger, engaging and advocating for marginalized groups of people, and developing mutual respect for each other.
South Oxford ManagementMaintenance Technician South Oxford ManagementMaintenance TechnicianHicksville, NJ$23–$25 / hourCompletes the “make-ready” process to prepare vacant apartment homes for leasing and new move-ins by completing the pre-move-out inspection, creating a “punch” list of maintenance work needed, scheduling vendors and contractors as needed, obtaining needed supplies and materials, completing all maintenance tasks, and inspecting completed work. South Oxford utilizes E-Verify, a web-based system that enables enrolled employers to verify the eligibility of their employees to work in the United States through the U.S. Department of Homeland Security and the Social Security Administration, subject to state law.
BluegroundMaintenance Technician BluegroundMaintenance TechnicianNew York, NYRemote$55,000–$65,000We’re now hosting guests in more than 50,000 homes in 46 cities around the world (and growing!), with an aim to hit 100,000 homes in 100 cities by 2025. Assist guests with maintenance/technical issues (electrical, plumbing, carpentry related to their stay at the property in order to support a positive guest experience.
Jamestowns Rental Properties LLCMaintenance Technician Jamestowns Rental Properties LLCMaintenance TechnicianJamestown, NYPerform various maintenance functions including but not limited to: painting, caulking, HVAC repairs, lock repairs, window/door repairs, electrical repairs, appliance repairs, preventative maintenance, and changing light bulbs, filters, batteries, etc. Maintenance Coverage after hours - schedule/execute on call rotation among maintenance team members to ensure someone is always available to handle service requests outside of normal business hours.
Atria Senior Living - LevittownMaintenance Technician Atria Senior Living - LevittownMaintenance TechnicianLevittown, New York$19–$22.80 / hourResponsibilities: Diagnose and repair problems in such areas as HVAC, electrical, plumbing, major appliances, carpentry, emergency systems, flooring, hardware accessories, masonry, painting/wallpaper, water features (pools, spas, etc.) and waste management systems. Able to frequently use general maintenance tools, supplies and equipment such as, but not limited to, hand tools, pressure washers, blowers, paint equipment, pool chemicals, ice removal equipment, ladders, landscaping equipment, sanders and safety equipment.
Atria Signature - West 86Maintenance Technician Atria Signature - West 86Maintenance TechnicianManhattan, New York$23–$27.60 / hourResponsibilities: Diagnose and repair problems in such areas as HVAC, electrical, plumbing, major appliances, carpentry, emergency systems, flooring, hardware accessories, masonry, painting/wallpaper, water features (pools, spas, etc.) and waste management systems. Able to frequently use general maintenance tools, supplies and equipment such as, but not limited to, hand tools, pressure washers, blowers, paint equipment, pool chemicals, ice removal equipment, ladders, landscaping equipment, sanders and safety equipment.
The Michaels OrganizationNewMaintenance Technician The Michaels OrganizationMaintenance TechnicianAlbany, New York$19–$22 / hourKeep accurate records regarding preventive maintenance, work orders, apartment refurbishing, annual inspections, inventories, purchase orders, and perform scheduled maintenance on all equipment based on the manufacturers operating manuals. Perform various maintenance duties for residential units including basic plumbing, electrical, painting, appliance repairs, cleaning units and grounds for inspections and new occupancy.
Rose Associates Inc.Maintenance Technician II - New York, NY Rose Associates Inc.Maintenance Technician II - New York, NYNew York, NYFull timeBased in New York City, we own, develop and operate leading properties in urban markets from Philadelphia to Boston and across all residential asset classes, including market, regulated, workforce and affordable housing. We rely on technology and the deep expertise of our team to consistently outperform the market in the operation of more than 30,000 units across some 250 properties in the most challenging housing markets in the country.
Rose Associates Inc.Maintenance Technician II / Handyperson - Winner's Circle, Ballston Spa, NY Rose Associates Inc.Maintenance Technician II / Handyperson - Winner's Circle, Ballston Spa, NYBallston Spa, NYFull timeBased in New York City, we own, develop and operate leading properties in urban markets from Philadelphia to Boston and across all residential asset classes, including market, regulated, workforce and affordable housing. We rely on technology and the deep expertise of our team to consistently outperform the market in the operation of more than 30,000 units across some 250 properties in the most challenging housing markets in the country.
Atria Senior Living - East NorthportMaintenance Technician Atria Senior Living - East NorthportMaintenance TechnicianEast Northport, New York$19–$22.80 / hourResponsibilities: Diagnose and repair problems in such areas as HVAC, electrical, plumbing, major appliances, carpentry, emergency systems, flooring, hardware accessories, masonry, painting/wallpaper, water features (pools, spas, etc.) and waste management systems. Able to frequently use general maintenance tools, supplies and equipment such as, but not limited to, hand tools, pressure washers, blowers, paint equipment, pool chemicals, ice removal equipment, ladders, landscaping equipment, sanders and safety equipment.
KMG PrestigeNewMaintenance Technician- Parkside Commons- Syracuse, NY KMG PrestigeMaintenance Technician- Parkside Commons- Syracuse, NYSyracuse, NY$25–$28KMG Prestige is seeking a Maintenance Technician to join our team in Syracuse, NY who enjoys new challenges, takes pride in their work, and is detail oriented. The ideal candidate will strive to create happy residents through providing superior customer service and timely service requests.
KMG PrestigeMaintenance Technician- Buffalo, NY KMG PrestigeMaintenance Technician- Buffalo, NYBuffalo, NY$23–$25KMG Prestige is seeking a Maintenance Technician to join our team in Buffalo, NY who enjoys new challenges, takes pride in their work, and is detail oriented. The ideal candidate will strive to create happy residents through providing superior customer service and timely service requests.
KMG PrestigeNewMaintenance Technician- Playter Gardens- Buffalo, NY KMG PrestigeMaintenance Technician- Playter Gardens- Buffalo, NYBuffalo, NY$20–$25KMG Prestige is seeking a Maintenance Technician to join our team in Buffalo, NY who enjoys new challenges, takes pride in their work, and is detail oriented. The ideal candidate will strive to create happy residents through providing superior customer service and timely service requests.
CRM ResidentialMaintenance Supervisor - Kingsbridge CRM ResidentialMaintenance Supervisor - KingsbridgeBronx, NYFull timeThe Maintenance Supervisor will be responsible for but not limited to: Responsible for the implementation and close supervision of the preventive maintenance system, to insure preservation and upkeep of all buildings and equipment, property housekeeping, completion of resident maintenance requests, prompt vacancy preparation for re-rental and for the employment and training of qualified and competent Maintenance Technicians, when necessary. Assist Community Manager with various inspections such as REAC, management reviews, annual unit inspections and local inspections and following through to make sure work orders are written and work gets completed in a timely manner.
Delta Sonic Car Wash Systems, Inc.Building Maintenance Technician Delta Sonic Car Wash Systems, Inc.Building Maintenance TechnicianBuffalo, NY$21–$30 / hourPart timePreferred skills for this position include but are not limited to: commercial property maintenance, electrical troubleshooting and lighting repair, plumbing repair, drywall, framing, and painting, overheard door repair, roofing repair, trailer towing, operation of aerial lifts, forklifts, skid steeds, or boom lifts, welding and fabrication, and certifications in OSHA, lockout/tagout, electric, forklift, or areal lift. Troubleshooting and repairing lighting, signage, plumbing, overhead doors, man doors, electrical components, drywall, framing, roofing, and other general facility-related issues .
InterSolutionsNewMaintenance Supervisor InterSolutionsMaintenance SupervisorNew Windsor, NY$32–$35 / hourAdministers maintenance software program to track work orders, inventory use, product replacement histories, and scheduled preventative maintenance. Proficiency in electrical troubleshooting of high and low voltage and the use of diagnostic equipment, including volt/ohm meters.
KMG PrestigeNewMaintenance Supervisor- Buffalo, NY KMG PrestigeMaintenance Supervisor- Buffalo, NYBuffalo, NYMaintenance Supervisors are responsible for overseeing a team of Maintenance Technicians, ensuring work orders are being completed timely, working with vendors, supply ordering, apartment turns, service requests, and overall maintenance of the apartment community. We are committed to growing a high functioning and talented team by integrating inclusion and engagement strategies into all recruiting, hiring, advancement, and retention practices.
AkeliusMaintenance Manager AkeliusMaintenance ManagerNew York, NYFull timehigh school diploma or GED required, technical certifications preferred, HVAC, EPA, electrical, plumbing or appliance repair certifications and HVAC CFC Universal Certification a plus. oversee external vendors to ensure they are completing their work and abiding by Akelius rules, building rules and Akelius code of conduct, ensure that property is completely secured and locked at completion of shift.
The Michaels OrganizationMaintenance Superintendent The Michaels OrganizationMaintenance SuperintendentWurtsboro, New YorkKeep accurate records regarding preventive maintenance, work orders, apartment refurbishing, annual inspections, inventories, purchase orders, and have full knowledge regarding contracts and suppliers, their services and goods. Participate in all maintenance projects, including periodically inspecting all units, buildings and common areas; performing repairs and janitorial assistance as needed as well as specific maintenance as detailed below.
National Property Management Associates IncMaintenance Tech National Property Management Associates IncMaintenance TechOrchard Park, NYVillage Center Apartments are looking for a service minded maintenance professional to undertake the responsibility of upgrading & preserving the good condition and functionality of our 96 unit residential apartment community. Conduct general upkeep procedures (e.g., landscaping) and other tasks as assigned (painting, carpentry etc.) and pool maintenance.
Cardinal Group Management&Advisory LLCMaintenance Team Member Cardinal Group Management&Advisory LLCMaintenance Team MemberIthaca, NYPart timeFollows Cardinal Group, city, state, federal, and EPA air conditioning and refrigeration record keeping requirements and procedures are met as to the maintenance, service, repair, and disposal of air conditioning and refrigeration equipment and refrigerant. Incumbents must be able to physically access all exterior and interior parts of the property and amenities and must be able to work inside and outside in all weather conditions including, but not limited to rain, snow, heat, hail, wind and sleet.
Konar PropertiesMaintenance Technicians-Residential Property Management Konar PropertiesMaintenance Technicians-Residential Property ManagementRochester, NYHighly Skilled Maintenance Technician in Residential Property Management needed at VIDA Apartments and Townhomes. 3 years' experience in the apartment maintenance or similar trade, plus experience in apartment turnovers required.
CRM ResidentialNewMaintenance Supervisor (Live In) CRM ResidentialMaintenance Supervisor (Live In)Bronx, NY$26–$27 / hourWe are seeking a skilled and experiencedLive-In Maintenance Supervisorto oversee the daily maintenance operations of a residential property in Kingsbridge, Bronx, NY. If you are a motivated and skilled Maintenance Supervisor with a passion for ensuring the smooth operation of facilities and equipment, we encourage you to apply for this exciting opportunity.
Brooklyn Community ServicesMaintenance Supervisor Brooklyn Community ServicesMaintenance SupervisorBrooklyn, NYCoordinates with necessary management staff to assure that priority needs for maintenance and repair are promptly identified and addressed in a manner which avoids disruption to the program operations Coordinates with the Director of Facilities determines needs for purchasing materials, equipment, and supplementary contractor services for required maintenance and repair of buildings, mechanical systems, fixed equipment, and grounds. Compassionate, patient, and empathetic approach when interacting with clients NYC Refrigeration Engineer License (Required) NYC Fire Dept - FLSD Certification (Required) NYC Refrigeration Engineer License (Required) NYC Fire Dept - FLSD Certification (Required) Building Maintenance Certification (COF/ FDNY) Examples: S12, S13, P98, T89 Proactive self-starter and a team-player.
BENE-CARETransform Property MGMT: Maintenance Supervisor BENE-CARETransform Property MGMT: Maintenance SupervisorCanandaigua, NY$26–$30 / hourThe Maintenance Supervisor is responsible for overseeing day-to-day maintenance operations across assigned properties while supporting and guiding maintenance technicians. The ideal candidate leads by example, assists with complex repairs when needed, and helps ensure the team operates effectively with minimal oversight.
Breaking GroundNewMaintenance Supervisor IV Breaking GroundMaintenance Supervisor IVBrooklyn, NYThe Maintenance Supervisor assigns tasks and coordinates inspections with tenants, supervisors, peers, and related city agencies; and oversees maintenance of building systems through work orders, purchasing, and building inspections. Supportive housing - affordable housing paired with services designed to help people maintain their homes for the long-term - is widely recognized as a proven and cost-effective solution to chronic homelessness.
Brooklyn Community ServicesNewMaintenance Supervisor - Family Shelter Brooklyn Community ServicesMaintenance Supervisor - Family ShelterBrooklyn, NYOur shelter programs are guided by a trauma-informed, strengths-based philosophy and offer a comprehensive continuum of services—including case management, housing placement, recreation, and supportive programming—to help families achieve stability and permanent housing as quickly as possible. Brooklyn Community Services (BCS) operates family shelters providing safe, supportive, and dignified transitional housing for families with children experiencing homelessness.
New York State JobsNewMaintenance Supervisor 1 New York State JobsMaintenance Supervisor 1Jamaica, NYUnder the supervision of a higher level Maintenance Supervisor or other administrative supervisor, the Maintenance Supervisor 1 is a working supervisor, supervising a combination of skilled, semi-skilled and unskilled subordinates, typically in the building, electrical, carpentry, roofing, plumbing, and locksmithing trade while the mechanical trades include the maintenance and repair of heating, ventilation, air conditioning and refrigeration systems and general machining and tool making for Division of Military and Naval Affairs facility assigned to them. Required to have or successfully complete within 90 days of receiving computer access, all training associated with assigned data systems such as SFS, GFEBS and the Statewide Learning Management System (SLMS) and/or other computer training as related to duty assignments.
StateJobsNYNewMaintenance Supervisor 2 (NY HELPS) StateJobsNYMaintenance Supervisor 2 (NY HELPS)Albany, NYOPERATING NEEDS: Ability to manage a staff of 15 or more and workload for multiple Downtown campus locations; obtain and maintain a working understanding of all ITM requirements of all direct reports including but not limited to fire alarm systems, fire and smoke door inspections, vertical fire doors and shutters, emergency lights and exit lights, portable fire extinguishers, emergency power systems, fire pumps, water-based fire protection systems, emergency showers, eyewash and drench hoses, fire hydrants, evacuation drills, and fire protection backflow preventers; obtain and maintain a working understanding of all hardware and software utilized by Fire Safety staff, troubleshoot, correct minor equipment issues; ensure staff are trained and capable of properly utilizing assigned equipment, hardware, and software employed to carry out daily assignments. Provide routine and detailed updates on staff assignments, assigned work orders, and fire and life safety systems ITM progress to direct supervisor (Assistant Director, Code Administration and Fire Safety) or, in their absence the Director of Code Administration & Fire Safety.
Post RehabMaintenance Supervisor Post RehabMaintenance SupervisorAuburn, NY$23–$25 / hourWe are hiring a full-time Maintenance Supervisor to support daily maintenance operations within our facility. Healthcare or long-term care experience preferred.
Conifer RealtyNewMaintenance Supervisor Conifer RealtyMaintenance SupervisorRochester, NY$26–$27 / hourAt Conifer Realty, being a Maintenance Supervisor means more than overseeing repairs — it means leading a team that keeps affordable housing communities safe, comfortable, and thriving. If you're a hands-on leader with HVAC certification, strong maintenance experience, and a heart for community, this is your opportunity to grow with a company that's been building affordable housing for 50 years.
Services For The Underserved, Inc.Maintenance Supervisor Services For The Underserved, Inc.Maintenance SupervisorNew York, New York
KMG PrestigeNewMaintenance Technicain- Buffalo, NY KMG PrestigeMaintenance Technicain- Buffalo, NYBuffalo, NY$20–$23KMG Prestige is seeking a Maintenance Technician to join our team in Buffalo, NY who enjoys new challenges, takes pride in their work, and is detail oriented. The ideal candidate will strive to create happy residents through providing superior customer service and timely service requests.
New York State Civil ServiceNewMaintenance Supervisor 1, Washington Heights Psychiatric Unit, New York State Civil ServiceMaintenance Supervisor 1, Washington Heights Psychiatric Unit,New York, NY$56,506–$68,630 / yearAdditional Comments All OMH employees receive a generous benefits package including:• NYS medical, dental, & vision insurance• Access to tuition assistance programs• Excellent opportunities for advancement & professional growth• Paid time off – 13 paid vacation days in the first year, 5 paid personal days, 13 paid holidays, & paid sick leave• NYS Retirement programsBackground checks will be required. Minimum Qualifications Candidate must have one year of experience as a skilled tradesperson with appropriate experience which will vary based on the assigned responsibilities in the mechanical, electrical, building or other trades subsequent to the completion of an apprenticeship or equivalent training and experience.